
The “Voluntary Pathway” — and How It Sidesteps Just Terms.
The Government now says its buyback will give owners a “voluntary pathway” to surrender firearms for compensation on a fixed-price schedule. But it pays to understand how that actually works. The scheme comes with a cap, a list of newly-prohibited firearms and a deadline — and once those are in place, nothing about it is really voluntary. In substance, owners will be left with three doors, and the Territory will have acquired their property without paying what just terms requires.
1. What the Government Has Actually Said
We are not putting words in anyone’s mouth. In its latest program update, the Government states plainly that the scheme “will give licenced firearms owners a voluntary pathway to surrender eligible firearms and receive compensation,” and that it expects “there will be a fixed-price schedule for individual licence holders.” Separately, the Public Safety (Firearms) Bill is described as limiting the number and types of firearms a person may hold.
Read together, those two sentences describe the whole machine. The Bill makes it unlawful to hold more than a set number of firearms, and unlawful to hold certain types at all. The “voluntary pathway” is then offered as the way to dispose of what the Bill has just made illegal to keep — at a price the Government, not the market, will set. The word doing the heavy lifting is voluntary.
2. How the “Voluntary Pathway” Will Operate
Strip away the language and the mechanism has four moving parts, which only work when assembled together:
| The part | What it does |
|---|---|
| The cap | A ceiling on how many firearms one licence may hold (the Bill proposes a limit of five, with narrow exemptions). Anything above the cap must go. |
| Recategorisation | Certain firearms — such as straight-pull shotguns and some centrefire rifles — are reclassified as prohibited. These must go regardless of how few you hold. |
| The commencement day | A date on which the new offences begin. On the Bill as drafted that day is to be fixed by proclamation, defaulting to 1 January 2028 if not fixed earlier. From that day, holding over the cap, or holding a prohibited firearm, is a criminal offence. |
| The fixed-price schedule | A set list of prices by firearm type — not individual valuation — paid to those who hand firearms in through the “voluntary pathway.” |
The sequence is the point. First the Bill makes retention a crime from a fixed day. Then the “voluntary pathway” is presented as the way out. An owner is free to join it in exactly the sense that a person told their property will be illegal on a certain date is “free” to sell before then. The deadline does the compelling; the schedule sets the price; and the label “voluntary” is what the Government will rely on to say it never acquired anything at all.
A “voluntary” surrender with a cap, a prohibited list and a commencement date is not a choice to participate — it is a choice about when to comply before the criminal law arrives.
3. Why “Voluntary” Is the Legal Device
Unlike the States, the ACT cannot make a law to acquire property otherwise than on just terms: section 23(1)(a) of the Australian Capital Territory (Self-Government) Act 1988 (Cth) withholds that power from the Assembly. If the Territory compulsorily acquires lawfully held firearms, it must pay just terms — full, fair compensation — and it cannot simply borrow the New South Wales schedule, because New South Wales, as a State, is not bound by that guarantee (Durham Holdings Pty Ltd v New South Wales).
That is the obstacle the word “voluntary” is designed to step around. If owners can be said to have chosen to hand their firearms in, the Government will argue there was no compulsory acquisition at all, and so no just-terms obligation to meet — which is how it hopes to pay a fixed schedule set below real value rather than fair compensation. The label is not decoration; it is the whole defence. But the law looks at substance, not labels: a scheme that makes keeping your property a crime from a fixed date, bars you from selling it to anyone who could lawfully hold it, and then offers a below-market buyback as the only realistic way to recover anything, is a compulsory acquisition in all but name.
4. The Three Doors Left to an Owner
Once the cap, the prohibited list and the commencement date are in force, an owner holding an over-cap or recategorised firearm has three doors — and only three:
Sell before the deadline. But every other ACT owner faces the same cap, so local demand collapses; interstate sale of a recategorised firearm is barred or uneconomic; and a prohibited firearm has no lawful buyer anywhere. The “open market” the Government points to has been closed by the Government’s own Bill.
Take the “voluntary pathway” and accept the fixed schedule. But a flat rate by type cannot reflect condition, make, rarity, custom or match-grade work; it is pitched at depressed, post-announcement prices; and it pays nothing for the ammunition, magazines, optics and fittings rendered useless once the firearm is gone. That is surrender for less than fair value — the opposite of just terms.
Hold on past the commencement day and the owner is, from that date, committing a criminal offence — exposed to prosecution, forfeiture and the loss of their licence. For a law-abiding shooter who has done nothing wrong, this is no door at all.
Forced to sell into a market the Government has crushed, surrender on terms below fair value, or become a criminal — that is the “voluntary pathway,” and it is why it is voluntary in name only.
5. The Government’s Own Standard: “Mr Fluffy”
The ACT has run a compelled “voluntary” buyback before, and set its own benchmark for fairness. In 2014–15 the Government bought back more than a thousand loose-fill asbestos (“Mr Fluffy”) homes. That scheme was voluntary in the same way this one is: owners who did not opt in faced compulsory acquisition and a home they could not lawfully live in. And the Government deliberately paid full market value — assessed as if the asbestos contamination that had destroyed the properties’ value did not exist — precisely so the terms would be, and be seen to be, just.
Why is an asbestos-riddled house, compulsorily given up, worth full market value — but a lawfully owned, perfectly functional firearm, compulsorily given up, worth only a discounted fixed schedule? By the ACT’s own Mr Fluffy standard, a “voluntary” buyback is paid at fair value. This scheme proposes the opposite.
Where SSAA ACT Stands
We have said from the outset that we do not oppose sensible, evidence-based firearms regulation. What we oppose is a scheme engineered so that the Territory acquires the lawful property of its own law-abiding owners while avoiding the compensation the law requires. On the record, the position is this:
- ✓The “voluntary pathway” only becomes a choice to surrender once the Bill has made keeping your firearms a crime from a fixed day.
- ✓A fixed-price schedule set below real value is not just terms — and the ACT, unlike the States, is bound to pay just terms.
- ✓The Government’s own Mr Fluffy standard was full market value for a compelled “voluntary” buyback. Firearm owners are entitled to no less.
If there is to be any buyback, it must be genuinely voluntary and paid at full market value — the firearm and the ammunition, magazines, optics and fittings that go with it — coupled with a five-year evidence review before the Territory binds itself further. Anything less is not a “voluntary pathway.” It is a compulsory acquisition on unjust terms, wearing a friendlier word. We will keep members informed as the Bill proceeds.
Our position is exactly what it has always been: no numerical caps, no recategorisation, and no mandatory buyback — and any ACT buyback only on just terms at fair market value, not an unjust schedule like that in New South Wales.
If you have questions about this update or the broader reform process, please contact SSAA ACT directly. We are here to help our members.

Sporting Shooters Association of Australia — ACT Inc
Media contact: info@ssaaact.org.au
SSAA ACT Inc represents approximately 5,000 members. There are approximately 7,000 licensed firearm owners in the ACT. These are distinct figures.
Sources: ACT Government (Justice and Community Safety Directorate), “ACT National Firearms Register Program update — Update 3, October 2026” (“voluntary pathway to surrender… fixed-price schedule for individual licence holders”); Public Safety (Firearms) Bill (limiting the number and types of firearms); Australian Capital Territory (Self-Government) Act 1988 (Cth) s 23(1)(a); Durham Holdings Pty Ltd v New South Wales (2001) 205 CLR 399 (States not bound by just terms); JT International SA v Commonwealth [2012] HCA 43 (acquisition and proprietary benefit); updated National Firearms Agreement, 26 August 2026 (no numerical caps, no recategorisation); ACT loose-fill asbestos (“Mr Fluffy”) Voluntary Buyback Program (2014–15), market value assessed disregarding contamination. The commencement date reflects the Bill as presently drafted and should be re-checked against the Bill before external quotation.